|
*This article was
published in the March 2006 issue of the Communique, a monthly magazine
of the Clark County Bar Association in Nevada, and was reprinted here
with permission.
THE NEW NEVADA
365-YEAR DYNASTY TRUST:
NEVADA
BECOMES A LEADING DYNASTY TRUST STATE
By
Steven J. Oshins
On October 1, 2005, certain provisions of Senate Bill 64 (“SB64”) from
the 2005 Nevada legislative session became effective. Those provisions
amended Chapter 111 of the Nevada Revised Statutes (“NRS”) to change
Nevada’s rule against perpetuities to 365 years. This new law creates
an opportunity for Nevada residents, as well as residents of other
states, to pass assets in a Nevada dynasty trust that is not subject to
estate taxes, creditors and divorcing spouses of the trust
beneficiaries for 365 years.
Prior to the passage of the new law, Nevada’s rule against perpetuities
under NRS Chapter 111 limited the duration of a trust under Nevada law
to the greater of 90 years or “lives in being plus 21 years,” which
generally allowed a trust to continue for approximately 90 to 120 years
before the trustee would have to distribute the trust assets to the
beneficiaries, thus moving the assets from an estate tax, creditor and
divorce-protected environment to one which exposes the assets to estate
taxes, creditors and divorcing spouses.
Because 17 states and Washington, D.C currently have laws allowing
trusts to continue perpetually with no estate taxes, prior to passage
of the new law Nevada had been at a huge disadvantage to the other
states and was losing significant revenue and jobs to the other more
favorable jurisdictions. Now that trusts can be created under Nevada
law for up to 365 years, very few Nevada residents will choose to
create trusts under the laws of the other states, and any non-residents
who otherwise would have created trusts under the laws of other states
will now choose to domicile their trusts in Nevada. Nevada is now one
of only a few states with a long perpetuities law as well as no state
income tax.
History of the New Law
Nevada’s Constitution at Article 15, Section 4 limits a trust’s
duration by imposing a rule against perpetuities on all Nevada trusts
except those created for charitable purposes. In 1987, the Nevada
Legislature codified this rule against perpetuities by enacting the
Uniform Statutory Rule Against Perpetuities Act ("USRAP"), NRS 111.103
to 111.1039, prohibiting trusts from lasting perpetually.
The original bill written for the 2005 Nevada legislative session was
authored by Steven J. Oshins and sponsored by the Judiciary with the
help of Senator Dina Titus as Senate Bill 382 (“SB382”). That bill, if
passed as originally written, would have increased Nevada’s rule
against perpetuities to 1,000 years. However, it passed and was signed
into law by the Governor on May 26, 2005, effective October 1, 2005,
with provisions extending Nevada’s rule against perpetuities to only
150 years.
Because of the inferiority of the new law as passed under SB382 in
comparison to the laws of a number of other jurisdictions, the
backers of SB382 were able to move the language of SB382 verbatim to
SB64, a bill sponsored by Senator Dean A. Rhoads, within a few days of
the passage of SB382, and the number of years was negotiated from 150
to 365 in SB64 and signed into law by the Governor on June 6, 2005,
thus marking one of the most significant changes in the history of
Nevada trust law.
What is a Dynasty Trust?
A dynasty trust is an irrevocable trust that leverages the estate, gift
and generation-skipping transfer tax exemptions for as many generations
as applicable state law permits. Whereas most attorneys draft
trusts to provide for mandatory distributions to the grantor’s children
at staggered ages (e.g., one-third at age 25, one-half of the balance
at age 30, and the balance at age 35), a dynasty trust is drafted to
encourage the trustees of the trust to keep the assets in trust for the
benefit of the beneficiaries and to allow the beneficiaries to "use"
the trust property rather than receive it outright where it will be
subject to estate taxes, creditors and divorcing spouses.
For estate tax purposes, it is not sufficient to plan for only one
generation at a time. The potential estate taxes that the clients'
children's estates may face as a result of such inferior planning are
often not given enough consideration by the attorney in drafting the
trust. As of 2006, the tax code allows each person to transfer up to $2
million without any federal generation-skipping transfer (“GST”) tax.
Meanwhile, the exemptions in 2006 for federal estate and gift taxes are
$2 million and $1 million, respectively.
Interestingly, the estate and gift tax exemptions are utilized in
nearly every estate plan, yet all too often attorneys do not draft
their trust agreements to utilize the GST tax exemption. Failure to use
an individual's GST tax exemption is a horrific economic waste over the
course of time. Most likely, this failure is a result of the attorney
using a canned “form” agreement that is more suited for a very small
estate but is not appropriate for a medium or large sized estate.
Designing the Dynasty
Trust
Most dynasty trusts are designed as Beneficiary Controlled Trusts. The
beneficiaries usually become trustees of their own trust upon reaching
the age at which most attorneys’ trusts would distribute the trust
assets outright to the beneficiaries. There are two general
classifications of Beneficiary Controlled Trusts – discretionary trusts
and support trusts.
Discretionary Trusts - For maximum creditor and divorce protection, an
independent trustee is used to make discretionary distributions and
other tax sensitive decisions. The primary beneficiary can be given the
power to remove and replace the independent trustee with or without
cause. Additionally, the primary beneficiary can be the investment
trustee thereby being able to make all investment decisions over his
trust assets. Thus, the primary beneficiary has the control over
and use of the trust property as though he owned it free of trust.
However, by having the dynasty trust as the owner, if drafted
correctly, the assets are protected from estate taxes and from the
beneficiary's creditors, including divorcing spouses. This
co-trusteeship, although slightly more complex than having just one
trustee, provides the ultimate combination of control, estate tax
savings and creditor protection.
Support Trusts - Alternatively, the primary beneficiary can be the sole
trustee. With this option, the beneficiary can only distribute assets
to himself for his health, education, maintenance and support. This is
often called a “support trust,” as opposed to a “discretionary trust”
which uses an independent trustee for discretionary distributions.
Although a support trust is simpler to administer than a discretionary
trust, certain creditors of the beneficiaries of a support trust may
access the trust assets, so it is less protective than a discretionary
trust.
The types of creditors that may access the assets in a support trust
depend upon which classes of creditors the court allows as exceptions
to the general rule that a spendthrift trust is protected from
creditors. Some examples of these “exception creditors,” as defined in
the Restatement Second of Trusts, include (1) alimony or child support,
(2) necessary services or supplies rendered to the beneficiary (such as
medical services), (3) a claim by the U.S. or a state to satisfy a
claim against a beneficiary (such as a tax lien), and (4) services
rendered and materials furnished that preserve or benefit the
beneficial interest in the trust (such as attorneys’ fees to protect a
trust).
Conclusion
The passage of SB64 has made Nevada one of the most favorable
jurisdictions in the country in which to create a dynasty trust. Nevada
residents, as well as non-residents, can use this new law to protect
assets from estate taxes, creditors and divorcing spouses for up to 365
years. The combination of the new perpetuities law with Nevada’s lack
of a state income tax makes Nevada an ideal jurisdiction. These
attributes make this one of the most historically significant changes
to Nevada trust law.
Steven J. Oshins is a
member of the Law Offices of Oshins & Associates, LLC in Las Vegas,
Nevada. His practice is focused on estate planning and asset protection
for high net worth individuals. He authored Nevada’s new 365-year
dynasty trust law.
|
|